top of page

The Scale Isn't the Whole Story

Writer: Coach Morgan
Coach Morgan
Oct 26
2 min read

Bare feet on a digital bathroom scale in a bright white room, with a rug and floor reflection, suggesting a weight check.

Let’s get uncomfortable here and talk about everyone’s favorite topic: weight.


Historically, weight has been the sole factor that providers looked at to determine health. Target weights were set, and people were determined to be “overweight” or “underweight” based on one. sole. number.


Now, there’s one problem with that: body composition.


The term, “Everyone’s body is different’”, didn’t come out of nowhere for nothing. Body composition is the proportion of fat mass, and fat-free mass (also known as lean mass) that makes up your body. Fat free mass is composed of bones, muscle, water, and organs.


How does body composition differ from BMI (body mass index)? BMI is another term often thrown around to describe the body. BMI is just a calculation of bodyweight and height, and does not represent body composition, or the amount of fat mass or fat free mass that makes up your body.¹ ²


By now, we’ve gathered that weight alone and BMI are not representative of overall health or fitness. So, why are we still looking at that number on the scale?


While you are busy crushing your goals in the gym, you may see that the number on the scale is not moving much. Yet another reason that the scale does not mean everything.


As you are gaining more strength (smashing PRs) and muscle, there is one thing to keep in mind: muscle weighs more than fat. Now, muscle does not actually weigh more than fat, but it looks a lot different. One pound of muscle weighs the same as one pound of fat, however, the density of each is much different, meaning one takes up much more space than another.¹ One pound of fat takes up much more space in the body than one pound of muscle does. Specifically, muscle is 1.06kg/L compared to 0.92 kg/L for fat.² So, 5lbs of fat is going to take up much more space than 5lbs of muscle will.


Due to the increased density of muscle, you may see that the scale is maintaining or increasing, but that your body composition is leaning out. This is due to the increased muscle mass that takes up less space per pound.


By now, we know that the scale does not represent everything, but if you are wondering why the number is not changing much despite success in the gym, just remember that fat takes up much more space than muscle, so you are likely just getting fitter.¹


- Coach Morgan


Interest in learning more?


Or




Resources


Comments


bottom of page
document.addEventListener('click', function(e) { var target = e.target.closest('a'); if (target && target.href && target.href.indexOf('gymmaster') !== -1) { gtag('event', 'conversion', { 'send_to': 'AW-17772405913/os70CJ_kvt8cEJnJxZpC' }); } });